|
Post by AC on Feb 12, 2011 18:37:57 GMT -5
MS Non-Wrestling Championship Alex (c) vs. Hurricane Amazing work by both. I really like both a lot and it's hard to choose but I think Alex takes my vote. It's really hard, I wanna vote for both King of the Ring Tournament: Final Round AVCore vs. Uksix Two more really good micros. I think I gotta pick UK. The thing that draws me away from AV is the shading up the middle of the singlet. Diablo vs. Attitude Adjusted (1) Gotta go with Diablo. Both guys did good but Diablo catches my eye more. Also the crotch shading on AA throws me off because it goes down really low.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 19:31:24 GMT -5
Match 1 Alex gets my vote. Brilliant all-round micro as always. Cane, I really like it, but some parts look kinda off, like the trousers shading, the trousers look too short, and the helmet seems like it's at an odd angle compared to the body. I honestly hate that you fault me for things that look perfectly fine and are meant to look that way. Not trying to be a dick, but the trousers are MEANT to be short and the mask is meant to look like that. I'm not trying to change your vote at all, I'm just saying at least know your material before you fault me for innaccuracies (shading/whatever is fair game). didnt i PM you the south park micros cane? No you didnt. You'd have figured this out days ago if you actually checked on the board or posted once in awhile, rather than just coming to see if you win or lose.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 19:40:02 GMT -5
Hurricane: 1 Alex: 3
AVCore: 2 Uksix: 3
The Elite: 1 Genesis: 1
Diablo: 5 Attitude Adjusted: 0
AC: 1 Masson: 1
Jake_666 wins by forfeit.
|
|
|
Post by Gav on Feb 12, 2011 19:40:28 GMT -5
Non Wrestling Championship Not an easy decision by a long shot. It's one of Alex's closest matches in a long time as we usually see squashes with him. Comedian's flawless and Boba's head is outstanding. But because it is flawless, I have to just go with Alex.
KOTR Wasn't that Ultimo used in a match before? Definitely seen it not too long ago. Sting's pretty good anyway as I see resemblance. AVCore here.
Six Man Tag I kind of wish Cane hadn't used AC's style because it leaves Hall looking like the odd one out. Having said that, I really like everything, but not so much the shape of Nash's head. Chest hair on Hall is great and Hogan is fantastic considering it's a new style for Cane. The karts look great but I can't use them as the reason to swing it your way. The most important thing is getting the micro right first, then accessories/pose can become a deciding factor only if needed. Since I don't think the guys themselves match up to the NWO, I'm going with Elite.
Best of Three Some good detail's gone into that Ultimo but I think Hurricane looks a little jaded, and the eyes aren't great. Diablo gets it.
Cruiserweight Whilst it was easier to see who Masson's was at first, after knowing it was Shaddix I did quite like it. I don't think the head of Jimi looks at all like him, much like James Brown if anything. AC here.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 19:44:08 GMT -5
Gav, but if I made it in a regular style, it would leave AC's looking the odd one out instead lol. I only made it cartoony because I had no interest to make it, and quickly threw it together on that so I didn't have to make all the shading, etc from scratch.
Hurricane: 1 Alex: 4
AVCore: 3 Uksix: 3
The Elite: 2 Genesis: 1
Diablo: 6 Attitude Adjusted: 0
AC: 2 Masson: 1
Jake_666 wins by forfeit.
|
|
|
Post by uksix on Feb 12, 2011 20:03:40 GMT -5
KOTRWasn't that Ultimo used in a match before? Definitely seen it not too long ago. Sting's pretty good anyway as I see resemblance. AVCore here. As Stated before, that is an old micro which you are reffering to, this is a new one. I was doing Muta in his entrance attire, but it was hard and plain colour wise with the one I got good caps of. I will vote tomorrow.
|
|
|
Post by MJH on Feb 12, 2011 20:19:01 GMT -5
Alex vs. Hurricane
Alex: Not a fan of this. Usually you're good at doing fine details but I just feel that the details on this particularly make the micro busy,things like the lines on the shirt the shading on the inner thigh and thigh plates, dont really like the colours either, dunno whether this is based off the movie or comic book version but either way the shades should probably be darker. Some parts are great like the gun, the shoulder pad and bullets but most of the attire I dislike. I also dont really like how big it is, I like smaller bodies with big heads but this is more in proportion which takes away from the cartoony style of shading you do.
Hurricane: Not a fan of this either, the green looks way too soft lit like it's silk rather than a shiny coat of green paint with chips in it. The helmet is quite good overall despite the green but the rest is quite meh to me. Most of the pads look way too pillowy and don't go together with the torso. The rest is ok but I just don't like that style of shading it's kinda pillowy kinda video game like just not fond of it.
Vote: Not very good for either of you but I'll go with Alex because overall the shading is better.
King of the Ring - Final Round
AVCore - main thing I don't like is the proportions, the arms are too short and the head is too small for a micro as far as I'm concerned. The rest is good but I don't like the shine on the singlet, its hard to tell where the light is coming from and basically looks like dried sweat stains that have lightened the clothes.
Uksix: It's ok, a bit generic but still good only major problem I have is the lack of dark shading to add contrast and depth so it looks a bit soft altogether.
Vote: Uksix, as the shaping is better and whilst it may be boring it's solid at the same time.
Six-Man Tag Elite - not bad but a bit boring, the shading on the first two is good but maybe a little flat, the third one is good too but doesn't go so much and the eyes seem a bit far apart, overall not bad but not that good either.
Genesis - it's interesting, I like the risk taken the luigi is definately the best, Overall there are some flaws such as some shaping and some parts that need more antialiasing but overall I like it.
Vote: Genesis, more interesting and better executed.
Best of 3 Series: Match 2:
Diablo - don't like the template it's a bit to straight and at attention, but the cape covers that up somewhat the shading is good, but I don't like the head again it looks too small and there's too much detail put into a small place making it look busy.
Attitude Adjusted - I like this in places, again there's a problem with the head size but the hair covers up that issue quite well and there's not too much detail for such a small place, the green is too dull, overall the attire is alright nothing amazing but by no means bad either. The main problem I have is that the grey of the main logo blends in too much and the white on the kickers doesn't blend in as much.
Vote: AA, close one but overall I prefer the shading slightly more on diablos but the shaping alot more on AA's.
Non-Wrestling Cruiserweight Championship
AC - it's good I like the tattoos and hair but it's getting to that point now where it looks like you just dressing up dolls with your micros because they look the same but with different hair and clothes, the shading is decent but there need to be something more to make it seem more unique per person other than the clothes particularly with this style as it's so distinct that it's hard to notice differences.
Masson: Really dont like this, hate the tiny head, maybe if someone could do a decent resembelance and non bug eyed look on these small head I'd like them but I don't see any resembelance in these. The shading is quite messy and the shaping looks bad which it seems you've tried to fix with anti aliasing which makes it look blurry.
Vote: AC, neither are spectacular but AC's is consistent and neater.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 20:21:22 GMT -5
Wow, really? I think both Alex and I done great. Boba is one of my best micros.
|
|
|
Post by MJH on Feb 12, 2011 20:23:22 GMT -5
Wow, really? I think both Alex and I done great. Boba is one of my best micros. really don't like either, the boba helmet is good but the rest doesn't flow as well, you've done alot better, and same with Alex it's good but it's not flawless and he's done a lot better.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 20:27:06 GMT -5
I hate Boba's pants, but just couldnt bring myself to redo them (im lazy). I love the rest. I dont think its one of Alex's best, but I still think its damn amazing, and it deserves to win. Im not exactly sure how anyone could vote AA's over Diablo's (no offence to AA, I know how badly he rushed it, and the shading is horrid and the green is totally off).
Hurricane: 1 Alex: 4
AVCore: 3 Uksix: 4
The Elite: 2 Genesis: 2
Diablo: 6 Attitude Adjusted: 1
AC: 3 Masson: 1
Jake_666 wins by forfeit.
|
|
|
Post by Masson on Feb 12, 2011 20:58:28 GMT -5
Match 1 Alex gets my vote. Brilliant all-round micro as always. Cane, I really like it, but some parts look kinda off, like the trousers shading, the trousers look too short, and the helmet seems like it's at an odd angle compared to the body. I honestly hate that you fault me for things that look perfectly fine and are meant to look that way. Not trying to be a dick, but the trousers are MEANT to be short and the mask is meant to look like that. I'm not trying to change your vote at all, I'm just saying at least know your material before you fault me for innaccuracies (shading/whatever is fair game). img268.imageshack.us/img268/7913/bobaref.pngAbout the trousers, his seems to gradually get thinner, where yours just end kinda abruptly, where it meets the white bit, if you get me. It makes it look like the trousers are too short and he is wearing some white socks, really high. With the head, there isn't actually a guy in the suit in that ref pic, and it still looks odd to me. Looking at a fer like this, the bottom of the mask is at a shallower angle, and I think yours would've looked better this way.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 21:06:33 GMT -5
I honestly hate that you fault me for things that look perfectly fine and are meant to look that way. Not trying to be a dick, but the trousers are MEANT to be short and the mask is meant to look like that. I'm not trying to change your vote at all, I'm just saying at least know your material before you fault me for innaccuracies (shading/whatever is fair game). img268.imageshack.us/img268/7913/bobaref.pngAbout the trousers, his seems to gradually get thinner, where yours just end kinda abruptly, where it meets the white bit, if you get me. It makes it look like the trousers are too short and he is wearing some white socks, really high. With the head, there isn't actually a guy in the suit in that ref pic, and it still looks odd to me. Looking at a fer like this, the bottom of the mask is at a shallower angle, and I think yours would've looked better this way. Fair enough I guess. Both are dependant on reference pictures I guess, as some are like you mention, and some are like I made. I think I used this reference for the bottom of the pants, 'cause I was trying to make them more interesting (some refs didnt have the white at the bottom of the pants, which made the pants look really plain compared to the rest.
|
|
|
Post by Diablo. on Feb 12, 2011 21:44:05 GMT -5
Match One: Both awesome micros... but Alex does it again. Absolute perfection. I can't fault Hurricane's, but everything about Alex's micro screams "epic". Thus, I give my vote to Alex.
Match Two: This match is really hard to pick a winner for. I love both of these micros as well, but Uksix's micro grabs me more, thus he gets my vote.
Match Five: I like both of these micros. AC's is really good, and so is Masson's. I have to give my vote to Masson here purely on the guitar, it's the only thing that sets a winner out of the two in my eyes.
|
|
|
Post by Hurricane on Feb 12, 2011 22:07:41 GMT -5
Hurricane: 1 Alex: 5
AVCore: 3 Uksix: 5
The Elite: 2 Genesis: 2
Diablo: 6 Attitude Adjusted: 1
AC: 3 Masson: 2
Jake_666 wins by forfeit.
|
|
|
Post by uksix on Feb 13, 2011 5:57:38 GMT -5
MS Non-Wrestling Championship Going to go with Hurricane here. Both micros are really great and I can't really see andy flaws, it is hard to choose one of them. Hurricane only just wins it as I love the helmet.
King of the Ring Tournament Final Round: Good luck AV
Six-Man Tag Team Match Have to go with Elite here. Genesis micros are pretty good, but there are flaws with them, and thats the characters. Don't get me wrong, it may of been hard, but I think the characters bring it dow. I really like Elites micros, and that Hulk may be one of my recent favurties. Scott and Nash are also really good.
Best of Three Series Match Two: Diablo wins it here. He is missing a few things on his attire but it is still a nice micro . AA's could be a little better but it looks alittle flat and his eyes/mouth look weired.
MS Non-Wrestling Cruiserweight Championship AC wins it here mainly because of the head likeness. Gav has said it in he's vote, the head doesn't look like Jimmy. It could be a really good micro as everything eles looks solid. Good work AC, I really like the style of you'r micros recently. Only thing I could suggest is maybe add a lighter shade to the hair, thats just me though.
|
|