Post by Next Generation on May 14, 2011 2:32:16 GMT -5
Ill add more details later
Match #1 Not bad micros from all 3 Vote: Emasson but just over Gavs
Match #2 All 3 are recognisable and all 3 are well made, Nice Horatio AC all round its very good, MJH thats near unfaultable, Haas if you had shaded a little bit better i wouldve given the vote to you for sure, really nice micro Vote: MJH
Match #3 Both micros are great, i think the only way i can split my decision is by going with the micro with more detail Vote: Jake 666
1x MS Cruiserweight Champion 1x Slammy Award Winner
Vote goes MJH. His looks awesome, the only thing I don't like about it are the hands. AC, It's a cool micro, just a little plain, the shading isn't anything special, IMO, and but still solid throughout. Haas, the shading is looking quite basic and not too great, if I'm honest. I dislike the low contrast style and the shaping on the arms make them look disproportioned to each other. Still, decent micro overall.
Match 3 Dean's micro itself isn't bad, the face is quite good, the shading is clean, and cool, albeit shaped oddly in places (lower insides of the leg), really dislike the claw hands and the shaping of the feet. Would've been cool to see him posed to one of hie signature dance moves though. Jake, you have been doing very unique micros as of late, which is great. I think the face of this one shows some resemblance, although he is looking much too old. Clothing shading is pretty cool, but I think you could've chosen a shirt with a logo or something on it to make it a little more interesting. Vote goes to Dean.
Sorry, I went to Mars for a second, but I'm back now and I've got T-Shirts for everybody!
2x MS World Champion 1x MS Wrestling Cruiserweight Champion 2x and Inaugural MS Cruiserweight Champion Hall of Fame 2013
Sorry Im not doing my usual critique-every-micro type of vote for this. I just really cant be bothered.
First match goes to Gavscsa, just due to originality and the immense detail. Shaping and detail is good, but I really dislike the shading as a whole. Due to its flatness and messy-lookingness. Nice micro choice, Masson.
Second match HAS to go to MJH, he excels at shiny/glassy shading like this, and this is no exception.
Third match is definitely Diablo, great work. Jake, I think you are a good microer, and at one point you were one of my favourites who I thought was going to be World Champion soon. This micro was a horrible, boring choice. It's like trying out for American Idol with "Hammer Time", no matter how good you sing it, its still Hammer Time and you most likely wont be taken seriously.
. Attire is just boring and theres nothing to really make it stand out, even if you had nailed the resemblence (which unfortunately you didn't). You need to try to make detailed original micros, and work on improving in general(though I must say, I LOVE the pants shading). Making a micro that looks like an average person walking down the street wont win any match.
Last Edit: May 14, 2011 18:45:48 GMT -5 by Hurricane
Looks just like every other Wolverine I've seen, and the pants shading can only be assumed to be a style he has seen from many people. I don't even think he would have used it as a reference, they look completely different.
EDIT: I'll vote tomorrow, I'm fucking knackered from lasertag.
It's very close between Masson and Gav to me. I like the originality of Gav's more, but the shading is better on Masson's. The forehead on Ermolli's is too big, and the rest is nothing special, but alright nonetheless. I think I'm going with Gav on this one. The head on Masson's throws it off for me.
I'm going with MJH as it's basically flawless. The shading is superb and it's just a fantastic micro. AC's would've been my second choice. I can't point out anything really wrong with AC's, MJH's is just better imo. Haas's shading ruins his for me.
Diablo it's a bit too cartoony, but still better. And that's what gets the vote. Jake's proportions are off and I have no idea who his micro is.